Monday, September 21, 2009

wine

i have just finished reading the Symposium

during Alcibiades' speech he says "truth comes from wine"

i wonder if there is any truth in this statement

my inclination is no but it's defiantly open to debate

2 comments:

  1. The argument here--which I'd say is partially true--is that when someone drinks their inhibitions are lowered and their guard is down. Therefore, they less likely to censor themselves and more likely to act on their thoughts, desires, or to say things they might normally keep to themselves. I think there's a good argument here for the ability of wine to bring about a certain measure of truthfulness but, as always, it depends on situation and it is certainly not foolproof.

    ReplyDelete
  2. i agree with everything you just said

    truth can come from wine

    the question however should have been if wine brings any useful truth

    in my opinion this is far less likely

    ReplyDelete